Pages

Thursday, February 23, 2012

First Line Grabber #24

TITLE: All Things Sunny
GENRE: YA - Sci-Fi

I thought it couldn’t get much worse than living with seven kids under the age of ten, a tired mom, and a neglected husband, but tonight it did.

51 comments:

  1. No.

    Okay, I want to say "Maybe" but Authoress will kill me if I break the rules... again.

    I mostly like this but it confused me off the bat. The "seven kids" sounds like they are the narrator's kids but then you go on to mention the mom and the husband and I'm totally lost as to who is speaking. The narrator needs to refer to these people as they relate to him/her.

    ReplyDelete
  2. No. Agreed that it's a little confusing. I don't know that that should put me off wanting to read more to find out (since to me, that's sort of the point), but I think we're meant to judge these based solely on what we're given, so I'm confused, so I'll say no.

    ReplyDelete
  3. No. I find this confusing. I assume the narrator is YA, so unless she's a child bride it doesn't make sense that she's living with a neglected husband.

    ReplyDelete
  4. No
    I am also confused as to who has the kids, who is the mom and the husband etc.

    ReplyDelete
  5. No. Agreed that it's confusing. It's possible the narrator is the wife, but that's not at all clear.

    ReplyDelete
  6. No. There's too much going on all at once and not in a way that pulled me forward.

    ReplyDelete
  7. No

    It's confusing and unclear. There are two possibilities: the seven kids belong to her, she has the neglected husband, and her mother is living with them OR there's a mother of seven, her neglected husband, and the narrator is a roommate? Clearing up the confusion would help us get hooked.

    ReplyDelete
  8. yes, but who lives with these people. I get the impression the person is not part of the family, so why does he live there?

    ReplyDelete
  9. No. It's confusing. I assume the narrator is a teen since this is YA (so the 7 kids are their siblings & the husband and wife are the parents, I assume?) but the fact that there's so much confusion in the comments means the voice isn't there yet.

    ReplyDelete
  10. No.

    It's confusing the family ties. And it makes it sound like the husband is the MC's but I am thinking it is supposed to be her step-dad? Also, are the kids her siblings? It's too much information without enough information to back it up. So I am left feeling lost.

    ReplyDelete
  11. No. I think too much detail was crammed into this sentence with a lot of telling. Show us Mom is tired and Dad is neglectful through their later actions.

    ReplyDelete
  12. No, too much information, no emotion really. I want to see this instead of being told...

    ReplyDelete
  13. No. I initially read it as the mother of the seven kids making the statement but now I'm just confused with the mention of mom and husband.

    ReplyDelete
  14. No. Guessing a lot of stories start this way: I thought it couldn't get any worse, and then it did. I'm betting you could make it work and sound fresh, but not as is.

    ReplyDelete
  15. No.
    Felt like there was too much crammed into the sentence and agree that it felt a little forced into a cliche.

    ReplyDelete
  16. No.

    It just didn't grab me. The list of awful things the MC has to deal with seems like it's going to be the conflict, but then you reveal the conflict is something else entirely, which makes me as a reader feel like I've overcommitted to the beginning of the sentence without any real payoff at the end.

    ReplyDelete
  17. No. It was almost a yes but I was a little confused. I need to know the relationship to the large number of people introduced. It reads like the Mom is speaking but then is referenced towards the end. I have to assume the husband is the MC's.

    ReplyDelete
  18. No.

    This line does not fit with this genre. My immediate thought is that the MC is a wife--something I find a bit unlikely in a YA book of any genre. Look at how it's worded--"a neglected husband"? Tired mom, I can understand. I'm a mom with 2 under 3. If it had read "with a neglected husband" (and no comma after "mom") I may call it a yes.

    ReplyDelete
  19. No. This sounds a bit like an older narrator (maybe the author) and doesn't give me a feeling for the MC. This sentence could work though if it was done in the MC's voice.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Yes - but...I think if you reworked/reworded this, it'd be stronger. Not sure any YA could indentify with seven kids (are they your MC's siblings?), a tired mom and a neglected husband. Its how they impact your MC, not what they are. Maybe " a neglectful mom" and "distraced dad?"

    ReplyDelete
  21. No.

    On this one, I can't tell who's speaking. It sounds like a "mom" but it's YA. The voice isn't working. Would a teen refer to someone as a "neglected husband"? It sounds like something an adult woman would say.

    ReplyDelete
  22. No. I found this very confusing with the "mom/husband" issue, as others have said. Beyond that, the "I thought it couldn't get much worse" approach is a bit cliche, to be honest. There were a couple agents complaining about this approach (referring to queries, but I still think it applies) just the other day.

    ReplyDelete
  23. No. This may be a great book, but there's too much back story crammed in here (seven kids, a mother, a husband) and nothing of current story other than a passive phrase (it did). Different shorter phrasing and maybe leaving out one element might let this work.

    ReplyDelete
  24. No. It doesn't flow smoothly. I found myself tripping over the words.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Yes, but just barely. I'd read the next sentence or two before deciding to commit to the story.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Yes. I'm curious to know how it got worse, in spite of some confusion in the sentence.

    ReplyDelete
  27. No. Like others have said, it starts reading like a wife speaking, but by the end, it seems to be a child member of the family. Would a child use the term "neglected husband"? or care?

    ReplyDelete
  28. Yes, but just because I have to figure out who the narrator is, or what this household is like. Is a married woman living with her mom still? It hooked me enough to want to find out.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I'm going to say yes, because I want to know more.WHY is this person living with 7 kids and their parents, and who is this person? Some cultures live more than one family per house,so it could be a combined-household, the MC could be living there because he/she is a foster kid or live-in nanny, her parents dumped her off with relatives/friends, and so on. The possibilities are endless and I would like to know, plus I'd like to know what the MC is hinting at that just made life worse.

    ReplyDelete
  30. No. But not because I don't think that doesn't sound like an interesting household. It's because (as others have said) I'm confused on who's speaking.

    ReplyDelete
  31. No. I'm confused as to who's speaking as well. You have a laundry list of characters here, but it's all kind of vague. Can you give specifics about how it got worse, or at least a hint?

    ReplyDelete
  32. No, sorry. It seems like the POV is shifting. The teenage mc would not refer to her tired mom and neglected husband -- it's her mother's husband, not the mc's. It seems like he needs to come in later, the neglected husband is her mom's point of view.

    ReplyDelete
  33. No.

    I was too confused about who belongs to whom to care about the story. I also got the feeling that the MC (who is supposedly YA) is a wife and mother, which is weird to me.

    The phrase "under the age of ten" didn't strike me as YA voice, either. Maybe "... seven snot-nosed kids..." or something that shows more voice and POV.

    Agreed that the "I didn't think it could get worse until it did" opening is tired. And we don't even get a hint at how it got worse. I don't know what's supposed to entice me about this, but I'm sure there's something there. Just dig it out and focus on the real problem rather than the living situation.

    ReplyDelete
  34. No. Didn't sound like a teenager to me. If she doesn't like living with a neglected husband, why doesn't she just pay more attention to her husband? Sounds strange for her to whine about something that's under her own control.

    ReplyDelete
  35. No, because even though the concept is decent (and RELATABLE no matter how many kids you have!), the wording was off.

    ReplyDelete
  36. No. I'm completely confused. Is the narrator an adult? She has a neglected husband and seven kids?

    ReplyDelete
  37. No. Sorry. This feels like a bit of an info dump, but I feel like it could be reworded to work.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Yes, but only just. I like stories about crazy blended families. nevertheless, I have the same reservations as the other commentors. I'm guessing the narrator is the eldest of eight kids and "neglected husband" refers to his/her step father, not her partner. And a teen would not care if the fellow was neglected or not.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Yes, but like some of the other comments (I only skimmed because I don't like to be biased), this was a close one. Mostly I was thrown off by the "neglected husband." Is it the narrator's husband, or the mom's? In which case, should that be "step dad?" With a little clarification, though, this could shine.

    ReplyDelete
  40. No. The POV is confusing: is the narrator one of the kids, the mom, the dad, or someone else entirely (in which case who)? I'm not really a big fan of the "I thought it couldn't get much worse than" setup, because of course we know what the answer is going to be!

    ReplyDelete
  41. No. I can't really figure out who the MC is. Also, it just doesn't grab me. I don't get enough from this sentence to really have an interest in what's going to happen.

    ReplyDelete
  42. No. Needs to be tightened and too much information is given away in the first sentence.

    ReplyDelete
  43. No - I want to say yes SO MUCH but I think a clarifier to say she's the sister of the kids is needed. LIfe couldn't get much worse than a sister of six siblings.. etc something like that. Just a bit of tweaking needed!

    ReplyDelete
  44. No. 2 reasons: 1, I'm not sure who the protagonist is - the mom? one of the kids? And 2, I'm not a fan of opening lines that go along the lines of "I thought it couldn't get worse, but then it did..."

    ReplyDelete
  45. No.

    It didn't sound YA to me. Plus, as others have said, it left me confused. The speaker sounded like a married who lives with her 7 kids, her mother, and her neglected husband. I don't think that's what you meant.

    ReplyDelete
  46. No.

    I'm not interested in spending a whole book with a narrator who seems to be throwing a pity party right from the start. I realize this impression could be incorrect, but that's how it feels to me with no other knowledge of your character at this point.

    ReplyDelete
  47. No. It confused me. Who is mom? The narrator or the narrator's mom? Okay - I see now that it's YA, so I'm assuming the seven kids under ten are the siblings? You might say that. But then, she would't refer to her dad as a husband, so I'm confused again. Also, there's no hook in this line - it needs voice.

    ReplyDelete
  48. No. I'm not sure whether the MC is one of the kids or their mother, or not related to the family at all.

    ReplyDelete
  49. No.

    Like a lot of the others, I'm confused about the relationships, and I don't like the "didn't think it could get worse but it did" cliche.

    ReplyDelete