TITLE: When Shayna Started School
GENRE: Picture Book
When Shayna started school, everyone thought she was the most
beautiful thing to enter Ms. Kelly's third grade classroom. Shayna
wore fabulous clothes from the most expensive stores.
Miss Snark's First Victim
Who is the narrator? Is it a kid? I wonder if it sounds too old for the character. Though Fancy Nancy uses some big words.
ReplyDeleteRight now this doesn't sound picture book to me. I guess it depends where it goes from here.
ReplyDeleteThe most beautiful girl in third grade? Doesn't seem a PB topic. More like MG or YA. Do third graders worry about beauty?
ReplyDeleteAlthough, if you had said 'prettiest' I might have bought it.
I agree with "prettiest girl" over "most beautiful thing."
ReplyDeleteHere, I think the voice sounds a bit old if this is another student.
ReplyDeleteYeah, the writing seems a bit too old to me, too. eg "most beautiful thing" and "enter" and "fabulous clothes", "most expensive stores". What is your target audience?
ReplyDeleteBased on the description of Shayna, I immediately concluded that this is a PB of an autistic child entering the classroom. I know a number of autistic children are described as beautiful. But the fabulous clothes from expensive stores doesn't set well. Young children shouldn't be encouraged to care or notice expensive clothing. I'd need to see the "moral of the story"--is the message that clothing and beauty can't cover certain problems?
ReplyDeleteIt read more like MG to me too. Does the teacher's name have to be in the first part? You could probably do more with the beginning with out it. Maybe:
ReplyDeleteWhen Shayna started school, everyone in the classroom thought she was the prettiest girl in third-grade. The children stared in awe at the beautiful clothes she wore.
I would read on. Keep in mind though that pic books are usually for kids younger than 3rd grade (kg, preschool) - so reading about 3rd grade may be outside of their scope. The vocabulary didn't bother me at all, as many great pic books have multi-syllabic words!
ReplyDeleteI think it's important to remember who your reader is and how your reader speaks and connects with your main character. The story idea sounds good; new kid in town...but you might want to think about the language of a third grader.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the other comments that the language doesn't seem right for what is being said. Although knowing who the narrator is could change that perception.
ReplyDeleteWho is your intended audience with this? If it's third grade, picture books are a little too old for that age set. I like to think it wasn't just me, but I was into Goosebumps, Judy Blume, and Rhald Dahl by that age. Some had illustrations, but picture books they were not.
ReplyDeleteChange it to kindergarten, make the tone more appropriate, and this is fine.
ReplyDeletenice!
viagra bekasi
alat bantu seks jakarta
hammer of thor asli bekasi
viagra cod bekasi
jual viagra cod bekasi
hammer of thor cod bekasi
viagra asli cod bekasi
obat perangsang bekasi
alat bantu sex bekasi