TITLE: MG
GENRE: Secret
“Jane, please come up to my desk.” It was silent reading time, so everybody in the entire sixth grade heard me get called up. I knew what Mrs. Watson was going to say even before I got there, but I didn’t care.
“Jane, your name is spelled incorrectly on every paper in your Bicentennial packet. These are official documents more or less, and therefore require correct spelling.”
In my head I yelled that I ought to be able to spell my name any way I chose and there wasn’t anybody who could stop me, but I was only brave in my head. Out loud I said, “yes, ma’am,” and went back to my seat.
I heard Pamela snicker when I walked by. Pamela Latimer hated me and I hated her back, but I had a good reason. She didn’t.
Contemporary realism
ReplyDeleteI don't think this has a "mean girl" MC, but perhaps she is being bullied? Perhaps there will be a coming of age element here.
Contemporary
ReplyDeleteHistorical
ReplyDeleteThe 'bicentennial packet' made me think this might be set in 1976, but it could just as easily be a reference to a state's bicentennial -- bringing a lot of other years into play. My other thought was that this might be set in some other futuristic culture, but nothing else in the excerpt felt sci-fi, so I took a gamble with historical.
Contemporary.
ReplyDeleteDidn't seem to have any specific markers of other genres.
Contemporary.
ReplyDeleteDidn't seem to have any hint of other genres, although I guess it would depend which "bicentennial" was being referred to.
Contemporary.
ReplyDeleteSeems grounded in reality, no hints otherwise yet.
Contemporary
ReplyDeleteIt seems like it's in the real world but the bicentennial packet through me a bit. Is it 1976 or is it something made up?
Realistic Fiction.
ReplyDeleteRealistic Fiction.
ReplyDeleteRealistic, guessing the MC has dyslexia.
ReplyDeletemodern school setting, girl can't spell her own name.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteContemporary
ReplyDeletebe interested to see how it goes with Pamela
Contemporary
ReplyDeleteThis was a tough one. Bicentennial suggests 1976, which isn't far enough back to be historical if this were adult, but I'm not sure what the historical genre rules are for MG. Another thing that tripped me up is the Bicentennial packet being an official document. I'm old enough to remember 1976, and I can't think of what these official documents are, which makes me wonder if this is actually sci-fi, and we're looking at a future bicentennial.
I would guess Contemporary. Obviously set in reality, but Lanette has some good points about the "official document," though grist of story seems to be something other than strict sci-fi/fantasy elements.
ReplyDeleteContemporary. I figure it's the bicentennial of the school or town.
ReplyDeleteNot sure. But for the bicentennial packet official documents, it sounds straightforwardly contemporary.
ReplyDeleteNot sure. But for the bicentennial packet official documents, it sounds straightforwardly contemporary.
ReplyDeleteContemporary?
ReplyDeleteIt feels a bit early in the narrative to call. I'm wondering how many ways you can possibly spell 'Jane' wrong...
Contemporary
ReplyDeleteThe bicentennial packet throws me off, though, but everything else feels contemporary. I want to know what the deal is with Pamela.
Contemporary. Perhaps the protagonist has dyslexia?
ReplyDeleteContemporary. But the possibilities are there to go in many directions further into the story.
ReplyDeleteContemporary. But the possibilities are there to go in many directions further into the story.
ReplyDeleteSCIENCE-FICTION
ReplyDeleteFirst, I thought contemporary, but then you mentioned "Bicentennial packet". That made me think Bicentennial man. Since these are her official papers... Could she be a robot?
Contemporary realism.
ReplyDeleteNothing clearly suggests any other genre to me.
Contemporary
ReplyDeleteThe packet could just be schoolwork, it feels like a realistic story to me.
Contemporary Realistic
ReplyDeleteJaine? Jayne?
Contemporary Realistic.
ReplyDeleteBecause it's set in fairly modern times (bicentennial puts it in 1976 which is not yet considered historical since its not set 50 or more years in the past). And because it seems to deal with the MC's social problems with a classmate as well as her feelings toward being told what she can and can't do. To me the opening hints of a possible "fed-up with bullying" scenario (Realistic).
Contemporary. It seems like a typical classroom setting. But, the part about Bicentennial packet makes me think it could be some sort of science fiction or dystopian book. Maybe Bicentennial has significant meaning in this 'other world'.
ReplyDeleteContemporary
ReplyDeletekid in school, no hint of historical details (bicentennial could refer to any number of things), no hint of fantasy or sci-fi details.
Bicentennial? Names like Jane and Pamela. And a kid who says "yes, maam," so I'm going with Contemporary or Historical Fiction if the 70s are considered that.(that makes me feel so old!)
ReplyDeleteContemporary. Or possibly historical, if it's the U.S. Bicentennial. (I think I read somewhere that for MG, historical can be less than 50 years. Also, given the pace of publishing....)
ReplyDeleteMG
ReplyDeleteSchool.....young
Thanks everyone for guessing on my genre. As many of you supposed, it does take place in 1976, so I would call it contemporary. I was intrigued by the comments wondering if Jane is dyslexic (she's not-she just wants to spell her name Jayne-it's more elegant) and wondering if it was a story about bullying (it's not). But this shows me that I have some work to do!
ReplyDelete