TITLE: Weight of Metals
GENRE: YA, Urban light SF/Fantasy
At breakfast my dad explains the irony of the civil war and the blood of names. He gets passionate about human rights and his voice keeps time with that patriotic cadence, but on an empty stomach, it's all static to me.
We ride to school together, winding back roads through a hybrid of urban street life and rural farmland to First Coast High. Most of my friends had his U.S. History class last year. They tell me he's a hard ass. I know this. He admitted he hit my mother once before she left. She's never come back.
Two weeks remaining in my senior year and there are three shoving matches at lunch and a whole lot of whistles blowing. I work through my sandwich quietly while Aryana stares at me over her Sunkist.
"Bae, what's wrong with you?" she says, swallowing. "You ain't saying nothing."
"Chilling."
"You listening or nah?" she burps. "Why that thot, Lena, in your face yesterday?"
I gather my trash. Lena's at the next table over and makes eye contact when she hears her name. Her caramel legs always slide so smoothly from beneath her cheerleading skirt. Her fingers move over her cell and mine buzzes. Aryana blocks my view.
"You ratchet," she says, loudly, but it's drowned out by my boy yelling my name.
"Bruh," Mack says, panting. "Your pops!"
"What about him?"
"He was breaking up a fight, caught one in the face, and swung back," he says, miming the motions. "I saw them put him in handcuffs."
I am not sure about the time frame here - contemporary or futuristic?
ReplyDeleteThe dialog reminds me of "The Country of Ice Cream Star" which takes some getting used to. I like the pacing.
I would keep reading out of curiosity. The dad is being arrested for assault, but I am still not sure if this is a regular school or SciFi. The "First Coast High" almost seems like a re-imagined US like District 12 or Panem.
Thank you for your comments! It's contemporary and it's an actual high school in Jacksonville, Florida that has been gaining a not so great reputation lately in the news due to violence. Inspired me to use it in my story. Also I taught 9th grade English, Reading & Creative Writing there and couldn't believe how much it's changed since I also attended this school many moons ago!!
DeleteLet's hear dad's passion with dialogue to grab the reader. Show MC's lack of interest with action & dialogue so a reader can relate to it. We need to hear MS's voice. Establish the conflict between them more during breakfast & the ride to school.
ReplyDeleteGood description of Lena! What kind of eye contact does she make? A glare? I am confused why Lena calls MC a ratchet.
Realistic dialogue between MC & friend & then Mack!
Thank you for your comments! Sometimes it takes fresh eyes to really see the telling over the showing. I'll get this opening page right. I'll work on weaving in that southern vernacular a bit better for those who don't hear this slang on a daily basis.
DeleteI'd rather hear the dad talk instead of the MC telling us what he said. The slang was a little thick for me but the pacing moved along.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comments! I'll ditto here what I said above and I appreciate you pointing that out.
DeleteI'd rather hear the dad talk instead of the MC telling us what he said. The slang was a little thick for me but the pacing moved along.
ReplyDeleteI like your style and the hints of your voice, though I admit to having somewhat of a tough time following the action here. It has me wondering if your story is starting in the right place. Would this be better served starting at "Two weeks remaining..."? I do like that powerful second paragraph, though.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I still haven't quite figured out "Why that thot" and "You ratchet." Not sure there's enough context.
Ultimately, I would be interested in reading more of this.
Thank you for your comments! And I believe your suggestion is great about the starting point! And I will work on weaving in the meanings of the southern slang words a little better. And I am ecstatic to hear your interest is piqued.
DeleteThe first three paragraphs felt like someone was telling me backstory. It's interesting backstory, but it needs to be woven in later. If this scene is about Bee and Lena at lunch, then the dad should either come up in their conversation or should be introduced when he's actually in the scene.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comments! And that's a great suggestion. I'm already revising!
DeleteI like the soft flow of narration. It eases me, and it's comforting.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I find the slang distracting.
Thank you for your comments! Sometimes dialect and vernacular takes a little getting used to. I will work on making a smoother transition into it, however, I believe for certain areas of the world and even the southern U.S., it tells so much more about the character and I hope to find a way to make it work.
DeleteI like the soft flow of narration. It eases me, and it's comforting.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I find the slang distracting.
I'm not sure about the first few paragraphs. It's too much backstory right at the beginning. I'd consider starting at a different place? Perhaps even at "Two weeks..."
ReplyDeleteI do like your dialogue though. The slang is a bit thick, but it makes your voice really strong, and I like strong voices!
Good luck!
Thank you for your comments! Everyone has been so helpful. My opening is already shaping into something so much better. I suspect I will be paying a lot of attention to my dialogue and voice in the revision, however I'm glad you saw the strength in it.
DeleteThe voice is so compelling, I'd keep reading just to dig more into the MC's relationship with the father. Just watch out with introducing so many characters in one go before we've gotten grounded in the MC.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comments! And always sound advice! I'll try to get a better handle on that.
DeleteI'm just going to chime in here on the slang as well...at first I thought it was great, I recognized some words that my son uses and my thought was "wow this writer definitely knows YA-speak" lol. However, to be honest, it started to feel like too much. It began to feel forced by the end, maybe sprinkle it in a little lighter? It started to feel too self-consciously placed. That is just opinion to take or leave. Your narrative on the other hand (First three paragraphs) really blew me away. I think your writing is great and I felt it was very professional. Only the excessive slang made it go splat for me.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comments, Amy! Because of everyone's help, I know I'll find a way to make this opening much better.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete